Beacon Jews Signed This Open Letter In Support Of Ceasefire Resolution
/
When the City of Beacon/s City Council was debating signing the Ceasefire Resolution which it passed, several Jewish community members in Beacon signed and published an Open Letter In Support Of A Ceasefire Resolution. That was a contentious time that has tempered today, but will not go away, as a Ceasefire was never established, Palestine continues to get bombarded by Israel, funded by the Untied States who is supplying the weapons to massacre Palestinians, and Israel has escalated its bombardment of Lebanon again.
Since that time, A Little Beacon Blog faced harassment from a few people, including an Anonymous Letter Writer who was relentless in sending dozens of letters to businesses in Beacon who do an do not work with A Little Beacon Blog. This action created fear in us, and hesitation to publish more. But we know we must continue on with the rest of the world in resisting this violent, colonialist takeover.
Worse, is the strain it has put on the Jewish community globally, who has risen up shakily but loudly to say “Not in our name.”
Below is the Open Letter as it has been published. Should it be updated, we will update it here as well. The original can be found here. More people who are Jewish and live in Beacon or pay Beacon taxes can sign here.
Open Letter From Beacon Jews In Support of a Ceasefire Resolution
If you are Jewish & you want to sign on, please go to: https://bit.ly/BeaconJews4CF
We are Jewish Beaconites who represent a wide array of Jewish spiritual, religious, and cultural practices and beliefs. We have a range of experiences with, perspectives on, and personal connections to, the land and people of Israel and Palestine. In all our diversity, we are united in our support of a Ceasefire Resolution for the City of Beacon.
Over the past weeks, we’ve heard some Jewish community members cite their fear of speaking out, fear of pro-Palestinian protestors, and fear of their own public comments being posted on social media in their opposition to a Ceasefire Resolution. The Rabbi of BHA wrote in our local newspaper that a Ceasefire Resolution “will strain, if not shred, the social fabric here in Beacon.” We have heard other Jewish leaders suggest that there is a sinister, antisemitic underbelly to the local Ceasefire movement. A highly inflammatory and personally targeted petition is circulating with the aim of discrediting the growing Ceasefire movement and painting it as broadly antisemitic.
As Jews, we understand what antisemitic hate looks and feels like. We know the fear. Our ancestors endured pogroms, concentration camps, expulsion, discrimination, and exclusion. We have lived through the rise of antisemitism and anti-Jewish violence in this country along with a rise in hate-crimes of many kinds over the past decade (and some of us live at the intersections of multiple marginalized identities). These traumas live in our memories and in our bodies.
We, too, were deeply affected by the events of October 7th. Some of us have loved ones in the region for whom safety is a daily concern. Many of us feel fear when speaking out publicly on this issue, due both to antisemitism, and to pressure to conform coming from within our Jewish communities. It is risky to enter a heated and difficult debate that directly affects the people and communities we love.
It is from this place of deep knowing that we say: we will not let our fear be used to silence the urgent cries of our neighbors, who are calling out, “Ceasefire, NOW!”
“In our Ceasefire Resolution debate here in Beacon, we are seeing anti-Zionism and critique of Israeli military actions being conflated with antisemitism. As is often the case when Jews confront criticism of Israel, discomfort is reported as danger, and complex language around activism and resistance is flattened into a simple attack on the Jewish people.
This is dangerous for Jews and non-Jews alike.”
Antisemitism exists in all movements, because antisemitism exists everywhere. It is all of our responsibility to confront antisemitism wherever it surfaces. In our Ceasefire Resolution debate here in Beacon, we are seeing anti-Zionism and critique of Israeli military actions being conflated with antisemitism. As is often the case when Jews confront criticism of Israel, discomfort is reported as danger, and complex language around activism and resistance is flattened into a simple attack on the Jewish people.
This is dangerous for Jews and non-Jews alike. For Jews, the conflation of Israel and Judaism means that Jews can be targeted for the Israeli government’s actions, regardless of their stance on Israel. For non-Jews, antisemitism is a serious accusation. When used broadly, and when not clearly defined, it can be defamatory. To be wrongly accused of antisemitism can result in harsh consequences; it can cost someone their job, reputation and standing, before the accusations can be addressed. We as Jews must call out when the threat of antisemitism is used to mischaracterize a legitimate call to action.
At the same time, we have heard our Palestinian neighbors describe experiences of explicit xenophobia and racism: being called “terrorists'' on our city streets, harassed at their places of work, and warned against wearing their keffiyehs. They confront racism in all its forms, all while their family members in Gaza are dying and their families in the West Bank are under constant threat and surveillance.
As Jews we have been taught about the Nazi Holocaust: never again. With over 100 Palestinians being killed every day, Never again is right now.
There is no time to wait.
“Many local Jews are in community and communication with our Palestinian neighbors, and stand with them. The need for conversation between and among Jews of differing perspectives has also been made clear by this debate.”
We agree that dialogue is a productive way of building understanding across lines of difference, and of addressing and rooting out bias in ourselves and others. And in the simplest sense, we are in dialogue. Many local Jews are in community and communication with our Palestinian neighbors, and stand with them. The need for conversation between and among Jews of differing perspectives has also been made clear by this debate.
These last few weeks at City Council we have been in lively and passionate exchanges about these issues. A call for mediated, formal dialogue, no matter how well intentioned or needed, cannot be used to divert attention from the urgent call for a Ceasefire. Palestinians do not have the luxury of tabling this in exchange for careful conversation. People are dying now, and we must act now.
We appreciate that the City Council is listening, and that there is renewed interest in pursuing a Ceasefire resolution.
We stand united for a Ceasefire Resolution, and against all forms of oppression including Islamophobia and antisemitism, and call on the Beacon City Council to pass a resolution now.
SIGNED:
(List in formation, will be updated several times daily. Current number of signers: 76.)
Abigail Shapiro Taylor Ward 4
Arthur Camins Ward 2
Avis Olsen Ward 1
Brandon Vote in Fishkill/Glenham, pay Beacon School Taxes
Daniel Fisherman Ward 1
Dan Spitzer Ward 1
Dara Silverman Ward 1
Daria Gates Ward 1
David Ross Ward 1
David Smolen Ward 2
Deborah D. Vote in Fishkill/Glenham, pay Beacon School Taxes
Diana Cowdery Ward 4
Donna Minkowitz Ward 1
Elizabeth Greenblatt Ward 1
Emily Joslin-Roher Ward 2
Emma Myers Ward 2
Erica Patterson Ward 2
Eve Morgenstern Ward 4
Gracelyn Woods Ward 2
Hana Feit I work, worship, go to school, or live part time in Beacon
Harper Horwitz Ward 4
Harry Teitelman Ward 4
Ilana Friedman Ward 2
Jen Clapp Ward 1
Jennifer Clair Ward 4
Jessica Simkovic Ward 3
Jillian Heller Ward 3
Joan Unterweger Ward 3
Joshua K. Burghardt Vote in Fishkill/Glenham, pay Beacon School Taxes
Julie Beth Napolin Ward 4
Katya Levitan-Reiner Ward 1
Laura Bellizzi Ward 2
Lauren A. Ward 2
Lauren Spiro Ward 4
Lev Olsen I work, worship, go to school, or live part time in Beacon
Lila Barchetto Ward 4
Margo Sivin Ward 4
Martin Z. Vote in Fishkill/Glenham, pay Beacon School Taxes
Masha Schmidt Ward 4
Matt Harle Vote in Fishkill/Glenham, pay Beacon School Taxes
Matthew Ward 2
MJ Witenberg Ward 2
Nicolette Dakin Vote in Fishkill/Glenham, pay Beacon School Taxes
Noga Cabo Vote in Fishkill/Glenham, pay Beacon School Taxes
Ori Alon-Ray Ward 3
Parisa Karami Ward 3
Paula K. Vote in Fishkill/Glenham, pay Beacon School Taxes
Paula King Ward 1
Peggy Ross Ward 1
Phoebe Zinman Ward 3
Randy Bennis Ward 2
Randy Patterson Ward 1
Ray Roy Vote in Fishkill/Glenham, pay Beacon School Taxes
Ray Simons Ward 2
Rebecca Wisotsky Ward 1
Rusty Stahl Ward 1
Ruth Danon Ward 1
Sadie Greene-Kaufman Ward 1
Sam Adels Ward 2
Sarah Capua Vote in Fishkill/Glenham, pay Beacon School Taxes
Sarah From Ward 1
Sarah Richardsen Ward 4
Sasha Stim-Fogel Ward 2
Sergio Perez Ward 2
Sharon Strauss Ward 2
Sheila Webb-Halpern Ward 3
Steve Gold Ward 4
Stuart Gabriel Ward 4
Susan Myers Ward 1
Suzy Konecky Ward 1
Tina Bernstein Ward 2
Tom Stringer Ward 3
Tyler P. Ward 2
Valerie Barela Ward 2
William P. Ward 3
Yael Korman Ward 2
